Fair value, three years in: the FCA names what good evidence looks like
The FCA has published its clearest signal yet on how firms should assess and evidence fair value under the Consumer Duty, drawing explicit lines between stronger and weaker approaches. For boards and executives in consumer finance, the review resets expectations on data, segmentation and the quality of fair value conclusions.
Three years into the Consumer Duty, the FCA has moved from principle to practice on fair value, publishing a review that distinguishes firms embedding it credibly from those still relying on description over evidence (FCA). The regulator's framing is pointed: fair value conclusions must be grounded in customer data, segmented by cohort, and tested against what customers actually understand about price.
Evidence, not description
Alison Walters, Director of Consumer Finance at the FCA, singled out one credit card provider that quantified cashback, FX savings and other benefits and set them directly against fees and interest paid, giving a defensible evidence base rather than a product summary (FCA). The weaker pattern she describes will be familiar to anyone who has sat through a product governance committee: relevant data exists, but scattered across documents, never reconciled into a conclusion. For chief risk officers and product heads, the practical message is that fair value memoranda built from assumption and narrative will not survive supervisory scrutiny. The bar is a coherent, quantified relationship between price and benefit.
Segmentation becomes the dividing line
The review's second move is more consequential for pricing governance. Stronger firms segmented customers by credit risk, product usage, distribution channel and vulnerability characteristics, and tested fair value across APR bands and risk-based pricing groups (FCA). Weaker firms treated the target market as homogeneous. That distinction matters because it directly implicates risk-based pricing models, where cross-subsidy between cohorts is often the point. Firms running differentiated APRs now need to demonstrate that each priced group continues to receive fair value, not just the average customer. This is a materially higher evidentiary standard than many consumer credit boards have been operating to.
The understanding overlay
The review ties fair value to customer understanding, suggesting that even a well-designed price fails the test if customers cannot grasp the real cost (FCA). That connects to a parallel FCA strand on retail investor behaviour, where new survey data shows only 36% of 18 to 40-year-olds would be made more cautious by a 'last chance to buy' investment pitch, against 65% who spot the same tactic in a horror film (FCA). The regulator is building a consistent thesis: disclosure and price only count if the customer can actually process them. For firms, this pushes customer understanding testing into the fair value file itself, not a separate workstream.
What boards should do now
The review is not a new rule, which is precisely why it carries weight. It tells firms what good looks like after three years of practice, and by implication what will attract supervisory attention. Audit committees should ask whether fair value papers quantify benefit against price, whether cohorts are tested separately, and whether customer understanding evidence sits inside the same file. Firms that cannot answer yes to all three are now on notice.
Fair value has moved from principle to proof. The firms that treated the Duty as a drafting exercise will find the second three years harder than the first.
Sources
Polar Insight helps senior leaders in financial services understand what their key stakeholders actually think before significant decisions are made.
Related insights
Insurance claims handling: the FCA signals a new redress architecture
The FCA and Financial Ombudsman Service have jointly published a thematic report on insurance claims handling, foreshadowing legislation that will mandate recurring joint reports. For insurers, this reshapes how complaints data feeds supervisory risk, enforcement pipelines and board-level conduct oversight.
Cyber guidance, not cyber rules: the regulators pick clarity over prescription
The Bank of England, FCA and PRA have proposed joint cyber resilience guidance after October 2026 recorded the second-highest monthly volume of cyber incidents reported to the FCA in five years. For senior leaders, the shift from rules to expectations transfers responsibility for defining 'good' cyber resilience onto boards and executive committees.
Fragmented liquidity: the FCA tells firms they are only seeing half the tape
The FCA's market activity reporter, launched in July 2026, reveals that firms relying on primary market data may be missing a significant share of UK equity trading. For boards and investment committees, this reframes best execution, liquidity risk and listing decisions ahead of the equity consolidated tape.
Stakeholder Signals
Consequential developments in financial services and other regulated markets, with one implication for accountable leaders.
