Skip to main content

Insurance claims handling: the FCA signals a new redress architecture

The FCA and Financial Ombudsman Service have jointly published a thematic report on insurance claims handling, foreshadowing legislation that will mandate recurring joint reports. For insurers, this reshapes how complaints data feeds supervisory risk, enforcement pipelines and board-level conduct oversight.

The FCA and the Financial Ombudsman Service have put insurers on notice. A jointly published thematic report on 19 November tells firms to keep claims moving, communicate clearly, and take ownership when third parties fail them (FCA). The more consequential signal sits beneath the findings: joint FCA-Ombudsman thematic reports are about to become a statutory fixture of the redress system.

From guidance to governance input

The headline statistic, that 79% of claimants report satisfaction, is the sort of number a chief executive might previously have cited as cover (FCA). It will not work here. The regulator has already opened six Consumer Duty investigations in insurance, including three focused on potential poor claims handling and fair value failures in home and travel (FCA). Chris Knight, director for insurance at the FCA, framed the report as helping firms 'understand our requirements so that claims are handled promptly, clearly and fairly' (FCA). Read alongside the enforcement pipeline, that is a warning, not an offer of assistance.

The redress feedback loop is being hardwired

The structural shift is the proposed legislation that will require regular joint thematic reports from the Ombudsman and the FCA (FCA). Complaints data has always informed FCA supervision informally. Codifying it means Ombudsman case volumes, decision patterns and uphold rates will directly shape future supervisory priorities and, by extension, s166 scopes and enforcement referrals. Boards that treat the Ombudsman as a downstream cost centre are mispricing the risk. The same data now travels upstream into the FCA's thematic agenda.

Third parties are not a liability shield

The report's instruction to 'take responsibility when problems arise with third parties working on their behalf' is pointed (FCA). Home and travel claims typically flow through outsourced handlers, loss adjusters and repair networks. The regulator is saying delegation of operations does not delegate accountability. That matters for insurers whose service failures, and whose complaint volumes, are concentrated in supply chains they do not directly control. Procurement, SLA design and oversight of outsourced claims operations are now board-relevant conduct issues.

The wider consumer redress push

The claims handling report sits within a broader programme. The FCA has secured more than £200m in compensation for motor customers with written-off or stolen vehicles, estimated £157m in annual savings from its premium finance fair value review, and £70m in annual savings from its GAP insurance intervention (FCA). An update on commitments made in response to the Which? super-complaint from September 2025 is due by year-end (FCA). The direction is consistent: value for money and service quality are being enforced as Consumer Duty outcomes, not treated as commercial choices.

For insurance chief executives and non-executive directors, the implication is narrow and immediate. Complaints MI, outsourced-partner performance and claims cycle times are becoming supervisory inputs with statutory backing. The firms that restructure their conduct governance around that reality in 2026 will spend less time explaining themselves in 2027.

Polar Insight helps senior leaders in financial services understand what their key stakeholders actually think before significant decisions are made.

Stakeholder Signals

Consequential developments in financial services and other regulated markets, with one implication for accountable leaders.