Fragmented liquidity: the FCA tells firms they are only seeing half the tape
The FCA's market activity reporter, launched in July 2026, reveals that firms relying on primary market data may be missing a significant share of UK equity trading. For boards and investment committees, this reframes best execution, liquidity risk and listing decisions ahead of the equity consolidated tape.
The FCA has issued a quiet but pointed warning to anyone trading, allocating to, or listing on UK equity markets: the data you are watching probably understates what is actually happening. In a blog accompanying CP26/30, Jamie Whitehorn, Head of Trading Venues and Corporate Finance Firms at the FCA, writes that firms relying solely on a share's primary market data may miss a substantial proportion of overall trading activity (FCA).
The numbers behind the nudge
The headline figures look reassuring. Between 2018 and 2025, the total notional value of FTSE 350 instruments traded rose from £2.1tn to £2.7tn, and the number of trades rose from 313m to 421m, a 35% increase (FCA). Adjusted for inflation, overall activity was broadly unchanged. The more interesting story is where that activity now sits. Trading is spread across a wider range of venues and mechanisms, and traditional feeds centred on primary venues capture a shrinking share of it. The FCA's framing is deliberate: firms may believe they are seeing the full picture of liquidity when they are only seeing part of it (FCA).
Why this is a governance issue, not a plumbing issue
This is not a market structure footnote. Consumer Duty, MiFID-derived best execution obligations and the Senior Managers regime all presume that firms understand the liquidity of what they buy and sell. If the FCA has publicly stated that single-venue data can materially understate activity, boards and SMF holders at asset managers, wealth firms and brokers can no longer treat their data vendor choice as an operational matter. The regulator has set a benchmark, the market activity reporter, and told the market it has been used by participants in the UK (73%), Europe (11%), the US (9%) and other regions (7%) since July 2026 (FCA). Firms that cannot explain why their internal liquidity measures diverge from it will have a harder conversation in supervisory meetings.
Listings, capital raising and the competitiveness argument
The sub-text is the London listings debate. The FCA explicitly links accurate measurement of trading activity to companies' ability to raise capital and investors' willingness to commit (FCA). If issuers and their advisers have been assessing UK liquidity using partial data, the case for London has been argued on an incomplete basis. Chairs of listed companies, heads of ECM and sponsors now have a regulator-endorsed tool to reset that conversation with boards weighing New York or dual listings. Expect it to appear in pitch books before year end.
What to do before the consolidated tape arrives
The market activity reporter is explicitly positioned as a bridge to the equity consolidated tape (FCA). Firms that wait for the tape to go live will be adjusting policies, models and client disclosures under time pressure. Those that reconcile their current liquidity and best execution frameworks against the reporter now will have a cleaner audit trail and a stronger hand with both clients and supervisors. The implication for senior leaders is simple: the definition of market data competence has moved, and the regulator has said so in public.
Polar Insight helps senior leaders in financial services understand what their key stakeholders actually think before significant decisions are made.
Related insights
Insurance claims handling: the FCA signals a new redress architecture
The FCA and Financial Ombudsman Service have jointly published a thematic report on insurance claims handling, foreshadowing legislation that will mandate recurring joint reports. For insurers, this reshapes how complaints data feeds supervisory risk, enforcement pipelines and board-level conduct oversight.
Cyber guidance, not cyber rules: the regulators pick clarity over prescription
The Bank of England, FCA and PRA have proposed joint cyber resilience guidance after October 2026 recorded the second-highest monthly volume of cyber incidents reported to the FCA in five years. For senior leaders, the shift from rules to expectations transfers responsibility for defining 'good' cyber resilience onto boards and executive committees.
Face-to-face banking becomes a statutory duty: what the Lloyd Review forces banks to rethink
HM Treasury has accepted the central recommendation of the independent Lloyd Review and will legislate to protect access to in-person banking for the millions who still rely on it. For bank boards, this converts a reputational and political pressure point into a statutory obligation co-designed with the FCA, industry and consumer groups.
Stakeholder Signals
Consequential developments in financial services and other regulated markets, with one implication for accountable leaders.
