Skip to main content

Cyber guidance, not cyber rules: the regulators pick clarity over prescription

The Bank of England, FCA and PRA have proposed joint cyber resilience guidance after October 2026 recorded the second-highest monthly volume of cyber incidents reported to the FCA in five years. For senior leaders, the shift from rules to expectations transfers responsibility for defining 'good' cyber resilience onto boards and executive committees.

The UK's three financial regulators have decided that the answer to escalating cyber risk is not more rules. Their joint proposed guidance, published on 19 November, consolidates existing requirements and supervisory lessons into a framework aligned with the NCSC's Cyber Assessment Framework, and does so against a backdrop in which October 2026 saw cyber incident reports to the FCA run 52% above the previous 18-month peak set in May 2025 (FCA).

A deliberate choice against prescription

Nikhil Rathi's framing is unusually direct for a regulator mid-cycle on a consultation. 'Our response shouldn't always be more rules,' the FCA Chief Executive said, adding that firms had asked for clarity on 'what good cyber resilience looks like' (Bank of England). This matters because it signals a broader supervisory stance: the authorities are willing to codify expectations around governance, identification, protection, detection, response and recovery, but they are unwilling to dictate the controls themselves. The flexibility is a gift and a trap. Firms gain room to design proportionate programmes; they also lose the cover that rigid rules provide when something goes wrong.

The AI and quantum overlay changes the board conversation

Alongside the core guidance, the regulators published 'effective practices' on AI and quantum, pressing firms to address vulnerabilities to AI-enabled threat actors and to begin considering the implications of quantum computing for the public-key cryptography underpinning financial transactions (FCA). Quantum risk is not an operational issue any CISO can resolve inside a planning cycle. It is a multi-year cryptographic migration that requires capital allocation decisions now. Boards that treat the effective practices as optional will find them cited back at them in future supervisory letters.

Why the timing is not coincidental

The Bank's most recent Systemic Risk Survey cited cyber as one of the risks with the greatest potential impact on the UK financial system (Bank of England). Katharine Braddick, CEO of the PRA, was explicit that regulators need confidence firms can 'detect, contain and recover quickly' (FCA). That is a recovery-focused test, not a prevention one. Firms whose cyber reporting to boards still centres on perimeter metrics and penetration testing results are measuring the wrong things against the regulators' stated priorities.

What senior leaders should do now

The immediate task for executive committees is to map current cyber governance against the CAF domains cited by the regulators and identify where evidence of effectiveness, not just activity, is thin. The second task is to put AI threat exposure and quantum readiness on the board agenda as standing items, not one-off briefings. Guidance without rules shifts the burden of proof onto firms to demonstrate they have thought seriously about both. Those that treat this as a compliance exercise will be the ones the supervisors visit first.

Polar Insight helps senior leaders in financial services understand what their key stakeholders actually think before significant decisions are made.

Stakeholder Signals

Consequential developments in financial services and other regulated markets, with one implication for accountable leaders.