Structuring a Section 165 Response That Protects Privilege
A practical guide to responding to FCA Section 165 information requests in a way that meets the firm's statutory disclosure duties in full while preserving legal professional privilege. Readers will understand how to scope, sequence, and document a response that is both credible to the supervisor and defensible in later proceedings.
A Section 165 notice is not a conversation. It is a statutory compulsion to produce specified information or documents, and the quality of the response shapes the FCA's view of the firm long after the request is closed. The harder question is rarely what to disclose. It is how to disclose it fully and promptly without inadvertently waiving privilege over advice the firm is entitled to protect, and without creating a confused audit trail that invites follow-up scrutiny.
Read the notice as a legal instrument, not a questionnaire
The first task is precise construction of what has actually been asked. Section 165 notices vary widely in specificity. Some request defined categories of document over a stated period. Others ask open questions that invite narrative answers. Treat each limb separately. Identify the custodians, systems, and date ranges genuinely in scope. Where the request is ambiguous or disproportionate, engage the case officer early to agree clarifications in writing. This is not pushback. It is the foundation of a complete and accurate response, and the FCA expects it.
Resist the instinct to answer narrative questions with freshly drafted prose that summarises legal advice the firm has received. That is the single most common route to inadvertent waiver.
Stand up the response team before collection begins
A defensible response needs a named SRO, usually the SMF with the relevant prescribed responsibility, a legal lead (internal or external counsel), a document review lead, and a single point of contact with the FCA. Everything flows through that spine. The legal lead should be instructed in writing at the outset, both to establish the basis for legal advice privilege over the response work itself and to make clear that litigation privilege considerations have been assessed where investigation or enforcement is in reasonable contemplation.
Decide early whether the response is being prepared under a dominant purpose that supports litigation privilege. That judgement must be real, not retrofitted.
Separate facts from advice at the collection stage
Privilege is lost when privileged material is blended into factual exhibits or quoted selectively to make a point. Build the response on two parallel tracks. On one track, assemble the factual record: transaction data, policies in force at the relevant time, meeting minutes, correspondence with third parties, system records. On the other, isolate legal advice, instructions to counsel, and privileged internal analysis. Do not use privileged material as evidence to support factual assertions unless the firm has made a considered decision to waive privilege over specific, defined content, with the consequences understood.
Be particularly careful with board and committee papers. Minutes that record the receipt of legal advice are usually protectable. Minutes that summarise the substance of that advice may not be, and partial disclosure can waive privilege over the underlying advice itself.
Produce a privilege schedule that stands up to challenge
Where documents are withheld or redacted, provide a schedule identifying each document by date, author, recipient, and the basis of the claim (legal advice privilege, litigation privilege, without prejudice). Vague or bulk assertions invite the FCA to push back and may be reported to supervisors as a sign of poor cooperation. A properly particularised schedule, by contrast, demonstrates rigour.
Cover letter: short, precise, and signed at the right level
The covering response should state what has been produced, what has been withheld and why, what searches were conducted, and what limitations apply. It should be signed by the accountable SMF. Avoid characterisations of the underlying facts beyond what is necessary to answer the questions asked. Every adjective is a hostage.
What good looks like
The FCA receives a complete, well-indexed response on time, with a clear privilege schedule, no inadvertent waiver, and a contemporaneous internal record showing how each judgement was reached. The supervisor's next question, if there is one, is narrow and technical, not foundational.
If you are reading this with a live notice on the desk, the immediate decision is who holds the pen on scoping and privilege, and whether that instruction is in writing today.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Section 165 override legal professional privilege?
No. FSMA preserves legal professional privilege. The FCA cannot compel production of privileged material under Section 165, but the firm must identify what is being withheld and on what basis.
Can we refer to legal advice in the response without waiving privilege?
Referring to the fact that advice was taken is generally safe. Describing its content, relying on it to justify a position, or quoting from it will usually waive privilege over the advice and potentially over related material. Treat any such reference as a deliberate waiver decision.
Should external counsel always be instructed?
Not always, but instruct them where the request touches contested facts, potential enforcement exposure, or complex privilege judgements. The cost of getting privilege wrong exceeds the cost of early advice.
How do we handle documents held by third parties such as auditors or consultants?
Assess whether they fall within the firm's control for the purposes of the notice. Where they do, collection obligations apply. Privilege analysis for third-party communications is fact-specific and should be run past the legal lead before production.
What if we discover responsive material after the response has been sent?
Disclose it promptly with a short supplementary covering note explaining how it was identified. Supervisors react badly to late discovery handled quietly. They react well to prompt, transparent correction.
Frequently asked questions
Does Section 165 override legal professional privilege?
No. FSMA preserves legal professional privilege. The FCA cannot compel production of privileged material under Section 165, but the firm must identify what is being withheld and on what basis.
Can we refer to legal advice in the response without waiving privilege?
Referring to the fact that advice was taken is generally safe. Describing its content, relying on it to justify a position, or quoting from it will usually waive privilege over the advice and potentially over related material. Treat any such reference as a deliberate waiver decision.
Should external counsel always be instructed?
Not always, but instruct them where the request touches contested facts, potential enforcement exposure, or complex privilege judgements. The cost of getting privilege wrong exceeds the cost of early advice.
How do we handle documents held by third parties such as auditors or consultants?
Assess whether they fall within the firm's control for the purposes of the notice. Where they do, collection obligations apply. Privilege analysis for third-party communications is fact-specific and should be run past the legal lead before production.
What if we discover responsive material after the response has been sent?
Disclose it promptly with a short supplementary covering note explaining how it was identified. Supervisors react badly to late discovery handled quietly. They react well to prompt, transparent correction.
Related guides
Structuring a Dear CEO Letter Response That Lands Credibly
This guide sets out how to construct a Dear CEO letter response that answers the FCA's concerns with evidence, candour, and proportionate commitments. After reading it, you will know how to sequence the response, calibrate tone, and close the loop in a way that builds supervisory trust rather than prompting further questions.
Structuring a Section 167/168 Investigation Response Strategy
A practical guide to building an investigation response that protects the firm's legal and commercial interests while demonstrating genuine cooperation with the FCA. Readers will finish with a clear framework for governance, document handling, witness preparation, and stakeholder sequencing in the first critical weeks of an investigation.
Structuring a Pillar 3 Disclosure Under CRR for PRA-Regulated Firms
A practical guide to building a Pillar 3 disclosure that meets CRR and PRA expectations on transparency while handling commercially sensitive information responsibly. After reading, senior leaders will know how to sequence drafting, govern omissions properly, and brief the board on the trade-offs that matter.
How to Structure a Recovery Plan Under PRA SS9/17 That Evidences Credible Options
A practical guide to building a Recovery Plan that satisfies SS9/17 by demonstrating genuinely executable options, calibrated indicators, and a governance spine that works under stress. Readers will finish with a clearer view of what the PRA is actually testing and how to evidence it.
Structuring a Solvency II ORSA That Evidences Forward-Looking Risk Judgement
A practical guide to building an ORSA report that demonstrates genuine forward-looking risk assessment to the PRA. Readers will understand how to structure the document, where boards typically weaken their own case, and how to present a capital position that stands up to supervisory challenge on its merits.
Where a specific question needs an outside answer, quickly
Polar Insight's Expert Network connects leadership teams with practitioners who can speak to a precise regulatory, commercial, or stakeholder question before a decision is finalised.
Explore Expert Network