Skip to main content

How to Structure a MIFIDPRU ICARA That Evidences Adequate Own Funds

A practical guide to building an ICARA submission under FCA IFPR that demonstrates genuine capital adequacy and sound risk judgement. Readers will understand how to sequence the assessment, calibrate own funds and liquid assets credibly, and engage supervisors in a way that stands up to challenge.

The ICARA is the FCA's primary lens on whether a MIFIDPRU firm genuinely understands the harms it creates and holds resources proportionate to them. Supervisory capital guidance (an individual capital guidance uplift or an own funds threshold requirement) is not imposed because a firm's numbers are too low. It is imposed when the reasoning behind those numbers does not hold together. The structural task is to make the link between harm identification, scenario calibration, and own funds requirement so clear that a supervisor can follow it without inference.

Start With the Harms, Not the Numbers

The K-factor calculation is the floor, not the destination. The ICARA has to begin with a harm assessment that is specific to the firm's business model: harms to clients, harms to markets, and harms to the firm itself. Generic risk taxonomies lifted from prior ICAAPs are the single most common weakness supervisors cite. Each material harm needs an owner, a quantification approach, and a clear statement of whether it is mitigated through controls, capital, liquidity, or wind-down.

What good looks like: a harm register where every item traces through to either a scenario in the stress testing, a line in the own funds threshold requirement build-up, or a documented rationale for why no additional resources are needed.

Calibrate Scenarios That Actually Bite

Stress scenarios should be severe but plausible, and tailored to the firm's actual exposures. A wealth manager with concentrated custodian relationships needs an operational scenario reflecting that concentration. A proprietary trader needs scenarios reflecting liquidity gaps in its instruments. Reverse stress testing should identify the point at which the business model fails, and the ICARA should explain what management actions would be triggered before that point, with realistic timelines and quantified capital or liquidity benefit.

The common error is scenarios calibrated to produce a comfortable buffer above the K-factor requirement. Supervisors notice. If your stress outcomes cluster neatly just above the floor, expect challenge.

Build Wind-Down and Ongoing Requirements Coherently

Under MIFIDPRU 7, the own funds threshold requirement is the higher of the amount needed to remain viable on an ongoing basis and the amount needed to wind down in an orderly way. These two assessments must use consistent assumptions about cost base, client behaviour, and operational capacity. A frequent failure mode is a wind-down analysis that assumes rapid client transfers while the ongoing assessment assumes sticky revenues. If both cannot be true, explain which prevails and why.

The wind-down trigger framework matters as much as the number. Supervisors want to see specific, monitored indicators, not vague references to board judgement.

Make Board Ownership Visible

The FCA reads ICARAs for evidence that the board actually engaged. That means recorded challenge on scenario severity, documented decisions on capital planning buffer sizing, and explicit sign-off on the key judgement calls. A board minute extract appended to the document is more persuasive than a signature page.

Where management and the board disagreed during the process, say so and explain how it was resolved. Clean consensus on every assumption reads as a process that did not test itself.

Present the Numbers With Their Reasoning Attached

Every material component of the own funds threshold requirement should be presented with: the harm it addresses, the method used to quantify it, the assumptions made, and the sensitivity to those assumptions. Avoid aggregated figures without build-up. If a supervisor has to ask how you got to a number, you have already lost the argument on defensibility.

The Decision Point

Before submission, ask whether the document would convince a sceptical reader who has never met your firm. If the answer depends on prior relationships or verbal context, rewrite. The ICARA is a standalone evidentiary document. Treat it as one.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much capital planning buffer is appropriate?

There is no fixed number. The buffer should reflect the volatility of your K-factor inputs, the reliability of your stress testing, and the speed with which you could raise capital if needed. Firms with concentrated revenues or illiquid balance sheets should hold more. Document the reasoning.

How often should the ICARA be refreshed outside the annual cycle?

Any material change in business model, risk profile, or control environment triggers a review. Acquisitions, new product lines, significant client concentration shifts, and material operational incidents all qualify. An ICARA that only moves annually when the business has changed materially will be challenged.

What triggers supervisory capital guidance most often?

Weak linkage between identified harms and quantified requirements, stress scenarios that lack specificity to the firm, inconsistent assumptions between wind-down and ongoing assessments, and absence of credible board challenge. The number itself is rarely the primary issue.

How should group context be handled for a solo ICARA?

Group support cannot be assumed unless it is legally enforceable and operationally reliable. If you place weight on intra-group arrangements, the ICARA must evidence the legal form, the liquidity, and the governance around them. Supervisors discount informal support.

Should the ICARA address ongoing regulatory change?

Yes, where change is foreseeable and material. Consumer Duty implications, operational resilience investment, and known upcoming prudential changes should feature in forward capital planning. Silence on known pressures reads as a gap.

Frequently asked questions

How much capital planning buffer is appropriate?

There is no fixed number. The buffer should reflect the volatility of your K-factor inputs, the reliability of your stress testing, and the speed with which you could raise capital if needed. Firms with concentrated revenues or illiquid balance sheets should hold more. Document the reasoning.

How often should the ICARA be refreshed outside the annual cycle?

Any material change in business model, risk profile, or control environment triggers a review. Acquisitions, new product lines, significant client concentration shifts, and material operational incidents all qualify. An ICARA that only moves annually when the business has changed materially will be challenged.

What triggers supervisory capital guidance most often?

Weak linkage between identified harms and quantified requirements, stress scenarios that lack specificity to the firm, inconsistent assumptions between wind-down and ongoing assessments, and absence of credible board challenge. The number itself is rarely the primary issue.

How should group context be handled for a solo ICARA?

Group support cannot be assumed unless it is legally enforceable and operationally reliable. If you place weight on intra-group arrangements, the ICARA must evidence the legal form, the liquidity, and the governance around them. Supervisors discount informal support.

Should the ICARA address ongoing regulatory change?

Yes, where change is foreseeable and material. Consumer Duty implications, operational resilience investment, and known upcoming prudential changes should feature in forward capital planning. Silence on known pressures reads as a gap.

Related guides

Regulation & Regulatory Change

How to Structure an Operational Resilience Self-Assessment Under PRA SS1/21

A practical guide to building a self-assessment that evidences impact tolerances with intellectual honesty, including how to treat mapping gaps as findings rather than hide them. Readers will finish with a clear structure, a credible approach to residual weaknesses, and a sharper view of what the PRA actually expects boards to own.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →
Regulation & Regulatory Change

How to Structure an FCA Business Model Assessment Response

This guide explains how to construct a Business Model Assessment (BMA) response that credibly evidences strategic viability and prudent risk ownership. Readers will learn how to sequence the narrative, align financial projections with stated strategy, and address weaknesses in a way that demonstrates genuine control rather than defensiveness.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →
Regulation & Regulatory Change

How to Structure a Pillar 3 Disclosure That Protects Competitive Position

A practical guide to building a CRR Pillar 3 disclosure that meets market transparency expectations in full while handling genuinely sensitive information through the mechanisms the framework provides. Readers will finish with a clearer view of how to sequence drafting, apply the proprietary and confidential carve-outs properly, and defend disclosure judgements to auditors, the PRA, and the board.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →
Regulation & Regulatory Change

Structuring a Recovery Plan Under SS9/17 Without Resolvability Drag

A practical guide to building a Recovery Plan submission that evidences credible, executable recovery options while avoiding content that undermines the firm's resolvability position. Covers the sequencing, stakeholder choreography, and judgement calls that separate a plan the PRA accepts from one that triggers follow-up.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →
Regulation & Regulatory Change

Structuring a Section 165 Response That Protects Privilege

A practical guide to responding to FCA Section 165 information requests in a way that meets the firm's statutory disclosure duties in full while preserving legal professional privilege. Readers will understand how to scope, sequence, and document a response that is both credible to the supervisor and defensible in later proceedings.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →

Where internal confidence may exceed external evidence

Polar Insight helps leadership teams test critical assumptions against stakeholder, market, regulatory, and operational reality before risk compounds.

Explore Stakeholder Proximity