Skip to main content

Brussels Is Losing The Development Race, And Business Has Noticed

European business leaders judge China's Belt and Road Initiative more effective than the EU's development approach by a margin of nearly eight to one, and they want Brussels to spend more, not less, to close the gap. For executives whose supply chains run through developing economies, this is a competitiveness question, not a charity one.

European business leaders have reached a verdict on the development race between Brussels and Beijing, and it is not flattering to the EU. In a survey of 536 executives across all 27 member states, 54% rate China's Belt and Road Initiative more effective than the EU's own approach, including Global Gateway. Only 7% rate the EU ahead. That ratio should concentrate minds in the Berlaymont as member states negotiate the next Multiannual Financial Framework and weigh cuts to external policy and development cooperation.

The headline numbers tell a coherent story. Executives are not lukewarm about development policy, they are impatient with it. 68% say European development cooperation is relevant to their own business or sector, 81% think Europe's economic competitiveness depends in part on maintaining strong relationships with developing economies, and 90% see countering strategic competition, including from China, as an important area of investment. This is a business constituency that has stopped treating aid as a soft-power indulgence and started treating it as infrastructure for trade.

Figure 1: Headline findings from the survey on EU development cooperation, including the 54% to 7% verdict favouring China's Belt and Road Initiative.
Figure 1: Headline findings from the survey on EU development cooperation, including the 54% to 7% verdict favouring China's Belt and Road Initiative.

The competitiveness argument is where the political case has to be made. With the EU running a trade deficit with China of roughly one billion euros a day, the idea that Brussels can retreat from the countries supplying Europe's critical inputs while Beijing writes the cheques is not a serious position. Four in five executives surveyed agree that Europe's economic standing depends on those relationships. That is not a rounding error, it is a mandate.

Figure 2: 81% of European business leaders agree that Europe's economic competitiveness depends partly on maintaining strong relationships with developing economies.
Figure 2: 81% of European business leaders agree that Europe's economic competitiveness depends partly on maintaining strong relationships with developing economies.

The appetite for more spending is the finding that will surprise ministries of finance. 61% of executives want the EU to increase its development cooperation commitment, with 39.4% favouring a significant increase and a further 21.6% backing a moderate one. Only 3% want a reduction, and 3.4% want programmes ended altogether. A further 22.2% want current levels maintained but made more effective, which is a reform position, not a retreat. The direction of travel in the data is unambiguous, and it runs against the current direction of travel in the MFF negotiations.

Figure 3: Distribution of executive views on EU development cooperation, with 61% backing an increase and only 3% wanting a reduction.
Figure 3: Distribution of executive views on EU development cooperation, with 61% backing an increase and only 3% wanting a reduction.

Where executives want that money spent is equally clear. Asked to rank priorities by net importance, the top two are countering strategic competition, including from China, at 90%, and critical raw materials and supply chain security at 89%. These are not development priorities in the traditional sense. They are industrial policy priorities delivered through development instruments.

Figure 4: Executives ranked priorities for EU development cooperation by net importance, with important and not important responses shown. Countering strategic competition and critical raw materials and supply chain security rank as the top two priorities, with 90% and 89% of executives respectively calling them important
Figure 4: Executives ranked priorities for EU development cooperation by net importance, with important and not important responses shown. Countering strategic competition and critical raw materials and supply chain security rank as the top two priorities, with 90% and 89% of executives respectively calling them important

The gap between priority and investment is where the policy failure sits. 48% of executives name critical raw materials and supply chain security as one of the two or three most underinvested areas of EU development cooperation. 89% call it a priority. That gap is the entire argument in one data point: the thing business most wants Europe to do abroad is the thing Europe is least doing. And 76% want the MFF budget maintained or increased to fix it, with 35.6% calling that very important and 39.9% calling it fairly important.

Figure 6: 76% of executives think it important that the EU maintains or increases its development cooperation budget in the next MFF.
Figure 6: 76% of executives think it important that the EU maintains or increases its development cooperation budget in the next MFF.

The practical implication for anyone with a stake in the MFF is straightforward. The case for protecting, and expanding, development cooperation spending is no longer a values argument that competes awkwardly with hard-headed competitiveness concerns. It is a competitiveness argument, made by the people who run European businesses, about the terms on which Europe will access the inputs it needs over the next decade. Treating the development budget as a soft target in the next MFF is not fiscal discipline. It is an own goal, scored in full view of a business community that has already said so.

Polar Insight helps senior leaders in financial services understand what their key stakeholders actually think before significant decisions are made.

Brussels Is Losing The Development Race, And Business Has Noticed