Skip to main content

How to Prepare a Credible Response to a Section 165 Request

This guide explains how to respond to an FCA or PRA Section 165 information request with the rigour, accuracy and timeliness regulators expect. After reading it, you will know how to mobilise the right people, control the production process, and engage credibly with the supervisor throughout.

A Section 165 notice is not a routine data pull. It is a formal use of statutory powers, and the quality of your response shapes how the regulator reads your firm for months or years afterwards. Treat it as a test of your governance, your records, and your candour. The firms that come out of these exercises well are the ones that organise fast, produce accurately, and resist the urge to curate.

Read the notice properly before doing anything else

Start with the exact wording. Section 165 notices vary in breadth, specificity and deadline, and the drafting usually signals what the supervisor is actually worried about. Identify the legal basis, the recipient (firm or individual), the time period, the categories of information, the format required, and the deadline. Note any explicit reference to attestations, personal responsibility, or SMF accountability. If the notice names an SMF, that person needs to be briefed within hours, not days.

Most firms misread the scope at this stage. They either interpret it too narrowly, producing a response that looks evasive, or too broadly, drowning the supervisor in material and signalling poor information management. Get this calibration right at the outset.

Stand up a governed response team

Appoint a single accountable owner, usually the General Counsel, Head of Compliance, or a senior SMF depending on subject matter. Around them, build a small core team: legal, compliance, the relevant business line, technology and records, and company secretariat. Document the governance: who approves scope decisions, who signs the final submission, how legal privilege is managed, and how the board or relevant committee is kept informed.

Engage external counsel early if the request touches potential enforcement, individual accountability, or legally privileged material. Do not wait until you discover something awkward.

Define search methodology and preserve evidence

Issue a legal hold immediately covering all custodians and systems in scope. Agree a defensible search protocol: custodians, date ranges, keywords, systems, and review process. Record every decision. If you later need to explain why a document was not produced, the methodology is your defence.

This is where firms most often come unstuck. Informal searches, missed archives, personal devices overlooked, chat platforms excluded: each becomes a credibility problem if the regulator finds the gap first.

Produce accurately, not favourably

The temptation to shape, summarise or contextualise is strong. Resist it. Produce the information requested, in the format requested, with clear indexing. Where context is genuinely needed to prevent misunderstanding, provide it in a short covering note, factual and sourced. Do not editorialise. Do not omit material because it is embarrassing. Supervisors notice both.

If you discover errors in previous submissions or in the firm's regulatory data during the exercise, flag them. Self correction is almost always treated better than concealment later uncovered.

Engage the supervisor in real time

If the deadline is unrealistic, say so early with a proposed alternative and a reason. If scope is ambiguous, ask. If you will produce in tranches, agree the sequencing. Supervisors generally respond well to firms that engage transparently about process; they respond badly to silence followed by missed deadlines or partial deliveries.

Prepare the follow up

Assume the response triggers further questions, interviews, or a skilled persons review. Keep the response team together for at least four weeks after submission. Debrief internally: what did the exercise reveal about your records, controls, or culture that needs fixing regardless of the regulator's next move? Those findings often matter more than the request itself.

The decision in front of you now

If a Section 165 notice has arrived, the first decision is governance: who owns this, what is the escalation path, and when does the board hear about it. Make that call today. Everything else follows from it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should we claim legal privilege over internal analysis prepared in response?

Only where it genuinely applies, and with legal advice. Overclaiming privilege is a common and visible mistake. Keep privileged advice separate from factual production, and be prepared to justify any withholding.

What if we find wrongdoing while preparing the response?

Escalate internally at once, take legal advice, and consider whether notification obligations under Principle 11 or SUP 15 are triggered. Discovering an issue during a Section 165 exercise and failing to disclose it compounds the original problem substantially.

How much context should we provide alongside raw documents?

Enough to prevent misreading, no more. A short, factual index and covering note is appropriate. Lengthy narrative framing reads as advocacy and undermines credibility.

Who should sign the response?

Usually the relevant SMF or an authorised senior officer, depending on the notice. The signatory must be able to attest personally to completeness and accuracy, so they need to understand the methodology, not just the content.

Does board involvement help or hurt?

It helps when calibrated. The board should be informed, understand the scope, and receive the final response summary. They should not be drafting it. Clear management ownership with board oversight is what good looks like.

Frequently asked questions

Should we claim legal privilege over internal analysis prepared in response?

Only where it genuinely applies, and with legal advice. Overclaiming privilege is a common and visible mistake. Keep privileged advice separate from factual production, and be prepared to justify any withholding.

What if we find wrongdoing while preparing the response?

Escalate internally at once, take legal advice, and consider whether notification obligations under Principle 11 or SUP 15 are triggered. Discovering an issue during a Section 165 exercise and failing to disclose it compounds the original problem substantially.

How much context should we provide alongside raw documents?

Enough to prevent misreading, no more. A short, factual index and covering note is appropriate. Lengthy narrative framing reads as advocacy and undermines credibility.

Who should sign the response?

Usually the relevant SMF or an authorised senior officer, depending on the notice. The signatory must be able to attest personally to completeness and accuracy, so they need to understand the methodology, not just the content.

Does board involvement help or hurt?

It helps when calibrated. The board should be informed, understand the scope, and receive the final response summary. They should not be drafting it. Clear management ownership with board oversight is what good looks like.

Related guides

Regulation & Regulatory Change

Structuring a Dear CEO Letter Response That Lands Credibly

This guide sets out how to construct a Dear CEO letter response that answers the FCA's concerns with evidence, candour, and proportionate commitments. After reading it, you will know how to sequence the response, calibrate tone, and close the loop in a way that builds supervisory trust rather than prompting further questions.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →
Regulation & Regulatory Change

Structuring a Section 167/168 Investigation Response Strategy

A practical guide to building an investigation response that protects the firm's legal and commercial interests while demonstrating genuine cooperation with the FCA. Readers will finish with a clear framework for governance, document handling, witness preparation, and stakeholder sequencing in the first critical weeks of an investigation.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →
Regulation & Regulatory Change

Structuring a Pillar 3 Disclosure Under CRR for PRA-Regulated Firms

A practical guide to building a Pillar 3 disclosure that meets CRR and PRA expectations on transparency while handling commercially sensitive information responsibly. After reading, senior leaders will know how to sequence drafting, govern omissions properly, and brief the board on the trade-offs that matter.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →
Regulation & Regulatory Change

How to Structure a Recovery Plan Under PRA SS9/17 That Evidences Credible Options

A practical guide to building a Recovery Plan that satisfies SS9/17 by demonstrating genuinely executable options, calibrated indicators, and a governance spine that works under stress. Readers will finish with a clearer view of what the PRA is actually testing and how to evidence it.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →
Regulation & Regulatory Change

Structuring a Solvency II ORSA That Evidences Forward-Looking Risk Judgement

A practical guide to building an ORSA report that demonstrates genuine forward-looking risk assessment to the PRA. Readers will understand how to structure the document, where boards typically weaken their own case, and how to present a capital position that stands up to supervisory challenge on its merits.

Regulatory submissionRegulatorsBoards
4 min readRead guide →

Where a specific question needs an outside answer, quickly

Polar Insight's Expert Network connects leadership teams with practitioners who can speak to a precise regulatory, commercial, or stakeholder question before a decision is finalised.

Explore Expert Network